This is the issue here. Everyone wants a hyper coaster, including me, but I also want to spend $30~million on park improvements. One of the things I've said before is that if I got my way with everything, the parks would be bankrupt by the end of the week. Obviously you can't have both, there is only so much money to spend. They've not been afraid to invest in the parks, and for the most part they spend it on pretty decent stuff.
But you can't deny what's been going on inside the parks either, and that's what I'm getting at. From the outside it looks like shit went down at Dreamworld, and insurance went way up, and before anyone could do anything someone from finance has just said 'we're not paying to insure it, whatever it is get rid of it' despite that leaving both parks looking well below their best right when they need the parks to be looking good (both from a traditional peak season POV but also just for public perception). Or it could be that the themeing was actually dangerous and Viking's was run past the point where it was safe to run it. Neither of those possibilities cast VRTP in a good light.
It's funny you should mention Pirate Ship; I've heard through the grapevine that the park did lament closing Pirate Ship, and looked into getting a replacement, but they then discovered it would be too tall and they couldn't get permission. Given they built Storm after that story was told I tend to think it was bogus or just one of those things where someone tells a story to justify a crappy decision. On a similar note Skyway was actually on the chopping block for a long time before it closed, like they knew they were getting rid of it a couple years before it went, and I remember someone buttered up the staff saying 'Once Storm opens Skyway with have to close because of how close it is'. That story came from an entertainment manager so who knows where they got that story from, but it's a weird story for someone to go ahead and make up. Of course Skyway and Storm went on to co-exist for a year or so before Skyway closed, so that story was also some made up to soften an unpopular decision. Heck I'm surprised no one has made the excuse that the reason Mammoth Plunge is still there is because if they took it down they wouldn't be able to build that tall there again (in the past the tower did stand without slides for a year or 2 so it's not that)
I got side tracked but the point of these stories is to say I'm skeptical when I get given some story about why something has to close, when the reality is components just reached the end of their life and it wasn't deemed worth it to replace, and I think there's a bit of that going on now. 'Oh we started to re-do the themeing then we realized it wasn't going to be done but we opened it anyway so guests don't miss out'. 'Yeah we closed the Flume ride but there's a new attraction coming in 3 years and that's why we closed it'. 'WnWS has seen it's attendance drop because of events at Dreamworld rather than the reputation for poor customer service and the lack od new attractions'. You can see why I'm skeptical about it right?
Like I say, I'm not knocking them for the investments they've made in the theme park division, clearly it's to be commended but I reserve the right to notice and bemoan the fact that despite all the money going in, the parks seem to be going backwards right now. That's not really something that's up for debate, the parks are going backwards right now.
Finally, as for our parks v American parks, yeah it's not going to happen that we get something on that scale for a long time. Low population combined with higher operating costs makes for a bad time for parks like that out here. I think sometimes though it is easy to lose sight of how good some of the stuff here is. Like Superman is a crazy good ride. WWF is also all kinds of awesome, likewise Giant Drop is that class with the really big boys. If Giant Drop wasn't here you'd see people saying 'could you imagine if we had a ride like that here?' and they'd be shot down in flames for being unrealistic. Yet there it is, having it's awesomeness largely taken for granted. There is really good stuff here, that's probably why I care as much as I do.