Yeah, and I quote;
I reckon I saw maybe ten stunts in all that time, but a shitload of yakkity-yakyak and what the blue fuck was with the dance?
tl;dr list of wtf;
Creepy cover version of instrumental of Highway to Hell.
Unclear who the audience are supposed to identify with.
What is with the bike ramp and BMX stunts?
You should never let the cast hot-dog to the crowd for longer than the stunt lasted.
Cotton Eye Joe? A song that was divisive even back in 1995 - in a new show more than two decades later? I can't even...
What's the point of the River Rats characters if they are going to dance with the Kurt Angles at the end of it?
Ratio of talk to stunts is waaaay out of whack.
What, we couldn't have spent any time on themeing up the boats except for the truck (whose wheels clearly do not spin, but other than that is decent)?
The cadence of the show is all wrong. Everything seems to be about having the stuntperson stand there in front of the crowd, say something asinine in the name of 'story', and then send the stuntperson off to circumnavigate the lake before they do their next trip, leading to dead air while we wait.
What/where was the 'big finish' stunt?
If you want to try and salvage something from this here's some tips;
The stuntpeople don't need to return to the main stage after every trick. Keep them in the water for the most part to allow them to be ready sooner.
There needs to be a clear progression in the scale of the stunts.
On a lake of that size you need to be prepared to run stunts that involve two or more stuntpeople on the same stunt (two separate stunts adjacent to each other is not the same thing).
Ditch the crappy A vs B narrative once and for all. The audience is not interested; you give them no reason to identify with your characters, not your cause. If you must keep it then instead of having them compete 'just cause' or 'for the lake' have them compete to give the best show to the fans. None of the bullshit fake rivalry - make it real; real stunt-people working on stunts to play to the crowd. At the end have both groups combine for some large scale stuff to end people off happy.
Do not do the dance. Ever again. Like, ever. I mean it. Don't.
Do something with the set on the island. I don't care what. Jump a boat through it, swing somebody off it onto a boat. I don't know, just something. It dominates the view and adds nothing.
Lose the BMX stuff. It is out of place and adds nothing to the show. We know Showtime does BMX stunts, but this is not the place for it.
Lose the hotrod. It takes a long time to get out there and does nothing for the show. This isn't a motorsport show, no matter how much you'd like it to be.
You need to find some more height in some of the stunts because this all felt a bit small-scale.
Never allow more than 45 seconds to elapse between stunts.